Why Are The Star Wars Prequels So Hated
This query: Why are the Star Wars prequels hated a lot originally appeared on Quora, the very best reply to any question. Ask a question, get an amazing answer. Learn from specialists and entry insider knowledge. You can comply with Quora on Twitter, Facebook, and Google Plus.
Reply by Ken Miyamoto, Produced screenwriter, former Sony Photos script reader/story analyst, former Sony Studios liaison:
Gosh, the place do I start
The prequels attempted to elucidate the mythos of the unique Trilogy, together with The Drive itself, as nicely as the back story of Anakin Skywalker and Darth Vader.
The actual fact is, the Power and the again story of Anakin, Vader, and the Clone Wars have been significantly better when they had a mystique about them.
With the prequels, we had trade federations, new villains in each episode, overbearing CG, and comical Jar Jar Binks (in addition to overly comical R2-D2 and C3-PO) shoved down our throats for 3 movies.
The prequels had been extra about the special impact sequences than precise storytelling, which is what made them so far more Much less believeable.
Once you watch the original Trilogy, you consider most of those worlds. The placement taking pictures, the flowery set designs, and Men’s Star Wars Stormtrooper Print Long Sleeve T-Shirt so on. You by no means received that with the prequels. As a substitute, you had primarily CG generated backgrounds. You never felt the feeling of realism that you did with Tatooine, Hoth, Endor, the Loss of life Star, and many others.
In brief, some tales are higher left untold.
I didn’t need to know that the Pressure is the trigger and effect of midichlorians.
I didn’t need to know that Anakin Skywalker was actually a fairly whiny and annoying kid and adolescent.
I did not must know that the Clone Wars began with some trade federation embargo of kinds.
I didn’t have to know to see a younger Boba Fett and didn’t have to know that his father was the subject of the Clone Wars.
These details were all the time finest stored in subtle references throughout the confines of the mythological storytelling of the unique Trilogy.
And what DID work in the prequels was underused and eliminated. Darth Maul ought to have had a three film arc. Jango Fett was beheaded within the very movie he was introduced in as properly.
And eventually, the whole driving power that the entire prequel trilogy was building to (The transformation of Anakin Skywalker into Darth Vader) was handled so poorly. Just terrible. When Vader is revealed in his go well with, it was seemingly written and produced as a terrible Frankenstein-type parody, full with horrible dialogue and that terrible moment the place Vader screams “Nooooo!” and raises his arms into air.
General, the prequels were pointless elaboration by a director/creator that clearly lost touch with the viewers of the Star Wars, as a substitute trying to seize a whole new generation of youngsters. Look at what he did with the fourth Indiana Jones flick! It is clear that he misplaced touch with the mythos of the boba fett tee shirt creation that he gave delivery to. Like an old man asking kids to tug boba fett tee shirt his finger, considering that that fifty-12 months-outdated joke still resonated and never even really remembering why it was funny in the first place.
Reply by David Stewart:
Because they don’t seem to be nearly as good as the first trilogy, and the expectations have been high.
And in addition because they’re just actually unhealthy motion pictures in their very own right. People discuss how the prequels dragged down the unique trilogy, however what they do not discuss is how the prequels would never have been any sort of box workplace hit without the original trilogy to give them a readymade assist base. If Phantom Menace had been the first Star Wars movie made, then it might just be a forgotten-about series of motion pictures by now with only a limited fanbase.
An enormous part of the attraction of the unique trilogy was the easy battle between good and evil. Darth Vader and Emperor had been bad, and Luke and Co. weren’t, and the bad guys wished to wipe the good guys out, so conflict ensued, and good films were the end result.
But the prequels were about commerce disputes. Identify a single good film ever made about a commerce dispute. There was loads of standing round speaking about stuff and having votes in senates and usually not doing attention-grabbing things with lightsabers. It was dull–even worse, it was badly written dull. If I’m going to watch individuals speak about trade disputes, then I would like to observe attention-grabbing characters delivering snappy dialogue. I don’t wish to spend my time listening to horrible writing while wondering, “Why the hell are these evil capitalists talking with Asian accents What’s that all about “
The unique trilogy had probably the most iconic villains in movie historical past and put him against some truly charismatic heros. AFI listed the greatest heroes and villains of all time in 2003. Darth Vader comes in at No. Three on the dangerous guys list, and Han Solo at No. 14 on the checklist of good guys supported by Obi Wan Kenobi (the Alec Guiness, authentic trilogy version) at No. 37. No characters from the prequels trouble the list in any respect, and the way may they The closest factor they should an attention-grabbing bad guy is Darth Maul, and he is solely in the trilogy for about 15 minutes. The one fascinating good man is Obi Wan, and that is primarily as a result of McGregor is doing an Alec Guinness impression.
The unique trilogy gave us a fantastic story arc with boba fett tee shirt an incredibly thrilling conclusion. At the tip of Return of the Jedi, we watched as the nice guys fell right into a trap. Han and Leia had been captured on Endor, the fleet was about to be blown up by the Death Star, and Luke was considering a move to the darkish facet. The nice guys had been losing and it was onerous to see any way out.
At the top of the third prequel, we watched a protracted and drawn out lightsaber battle between four protagonists (Yoda versus Palpatine and Obi-wan versus Anakin) who we knew had been going to survive anyway. There was no tension, no pleasure, simply a way of relief that it was all finally ending.
We might in all probability have forgiven the extremely bad dialogue, pointless plots, and lack of character if the universe hadn’t been populated with added irritation. Jar Jar was a huge mistake on each stage. He wasn’t humorous at all, and the necessity to insert him into each scene made him even more annoying. He bumbled around within the background of conversations, he stepped in shit, got farted on, and customarily behaved like the most affordable comic relief character there was. And he by no means had a moment of redemption. He never redeemed himself with any courage or moment of intuition; he just screwed up throughout your entire film. The original trilogy did not want a purely comic relief character–it was capable of intuitively find comedic moments in the course of the film. Jar Jar, along with the two incredibly annoying Anakins, have been just irritating throughout your entire trilogy.
But that alone isn’t enough to inspire hatred. The prequels are boring and annoying and soulless, but then so are a number of different motion pictures. The explanation everyone should hate them is as a result of they take away from the original trilogy. Earlier than they made the prequels, Anakin Skywalker was a superb pilot lured to the darkish facet of the power. But now we all know he is a whiny and annoying child and a hopelessly acted romantic idiot and inexplicably the man who designed C3PO and R2D2’s best pal. And Darth Vader wasn’t the baddest of the bad who had his moment of redemption–he was a hopeless loser shouting a hilariously awful “Noooooo” to the heavens.
They’re just unhealthy films. And so they’re bad movies that made nice movies sort of worse. No surprise folks hate them.
More questions on Quora:
Star Wars Films: My son is ready to look at Star Wars for the primary time: What are finest practices
Movies: What are the best film soundtracks
Star Wars: Did the Rebel Alliance really blow up the Dying Star, or was it all planned by Vader and the Emperor to drum up support for his or her battle against the terrorists